REASONABLY POLYMORPHIC
ARCHIVES

New Notation for Abstract Scales

← music, notation

HA HA HA I SNUCK OUT AND DID SOME MUSIC!!! (after some encouragement from my wife!)

Anyway, just a quick little update on some new notation I’ve been working on. Hopefully this will more clearly elucidate the points I’m trying to make with these abstract scales and generalized accidentals.

Here’s what the new notation looks like:

3 Octaves of a 4-Note Scale

This is a 3-octave run in a 4-note scale. How can you tell it’s in a 4-note scale? Because the clef is a big “4”.

In the first bar, we have an -4 ottava bracket, which means we ought to read this bar to be one octave lower than it’s notated. The second bar is missing this bracket, and is therefore one octave up. And the third bar is an octave higher again.

As a couple of landmarks: the bottom staff line is always a “root” or a “tonic” in this scale. That’s why both the first and second bars start on the bottom staff line. There is always a second octave notated, as indicated by the line straddled by the }: symbol in the clef. If you look, this line is where the third measure starts.

What exactly does this scale “sound” like, you might be wondering? It doesn’t sound like anything; it’s just twelve steps in some arbitrary 4-note scale. We’d have to pin down exactly what that scale was in order to be able to realize it into something audible.

Let’s take another example. This next one is a 5-octave run in a 3-note scale:

5 Octaves of a 3-Note Scale

The conventions are exactly the same here. Each measure spans an octave, and each measure is an octave above the previous one. The bottom staff line is still the tonic, but here, the second staff space is the one straddled by the }:. Again, this acts as a little landmark for where the next octave lands. Notice that bar 3 begins on this space.

The only other thing to notice here is we have a +6 ottava in the last two bars. This is indicate it’s two octaves above what’s notated. It’s +6 because we’re two octaves above in a 3-note scale, and you shouldn’t be surprised to learn that 3 * 2 = 6.

Let’s take this same 5-octave in a 3-note scale and transform it into a 7-note scale. The way we’re going to do that is via this mapping:

triad :: Note 3 -> Note 7
triad 0 = 0
triad 1 = 2
triad 2 = 4

Here you should read 0 is the root of the scale, 1 as the next note above that, 2 as the next note again, etc. In our 3-note scale, we only have three notes, so giving a mapping for each of 0, 1, and 2 is sufficient to map every pitch class out of the scale. Here we’re mapping to every other note in a 7-note scale, which when you look at it, is exactly how we build diatonic triads. Take every second note in the 7-note scale, and that gives you a triad!

So when we apply this mapping over our 3-note scale example, we end up with arpeggiation of a triad over 5 octaves:

5 Arpeggiations in a 7-Note Scale

Technically this is an abstract 7-note scale, but we can choose to interpret it as the usual diatonic scale. As a matter of convention, we will map the tonic of our abstract 7-note to C in the diatonic scale. This brings us back to everyday musical notation that should be familiar to practitioners:

5 Arpeggiations in the Diatonic Scale

Notice that this diagram carries exactly the same information as the previous one, so it can be useful as a sort-of Rosetta Stone to help get an intuition for what the abstract notation is trying to articulate.

A More Musical Example

So that’s a quick little primer on the notation. But now let’s try something a little more musical. We can bring in the same motif that we used previously:

Motif in a 3-Note Scale

You’ll notice the familiar “abstract 3 clef”. The only new thing in this example are the accidentals. Unlike in a previous post, they are now using standard sharps/flats/natural symbols. But they also have little subscripts — the third note has a subscript 7 and the fourth note has a subscript 12.

These subscripts express which scale we want to apply the accidental to. The #/7 means “move up one scale degree in a 7-note (diatonic) scale”. The “b/12” means “move down one scale degree in a 12-note (chromatic) scale.”

We’ll expand this out momentarily to get some intuition as to what this means musically.

Let’s repeat the motif 3 times, each time up a single scale degree:

Repeated Motif in a 3-Note Scale

Using the same triad mapping as before, we can move this repeated motif into an abstract 7-note scale:

Repeated Motif in a 7-Note Scale

There are two things to notice here. The first is that this thing looks much less like an arpeggiation than our first example. And the second is that the #/7s are gone! These two facts are related to one another.

Recall that #/7 was notation for “move up one note in a 7-note scale”. And so now that we’re in a 7-note scale, we can drop the notation and just move up one note. But since we haven’t yet moved into a 12-note scale, we can’t do the same procedure to the b/12s, and so those accidentals remain.

Let’s now reinterpret this abstract 7-note scale as the usual diatonic scale:

Repeated Motif in the Diatonic Scale

which again should be familiar ground to musicians. You’ll notice that the b/12 have been replaced by simple flats, because standard music notation actually expresses the diatonic scale, and uses accidentals to express chromatic moves.

Check out this music we’ve composed! What was once a very simple pattern in Note 3 now has some character!

By Way Of Some Other Mappings

Of course, nobody says we need to interpret our 3-note scale as triads. We could instead take our same repeated motif and map it into a 5-note scale. To pick a mapping at random, let’s go with:

toFive :: Note 3 -> Note 5
toFive 0 = 0
toFive 1 = 3
toFive 2 = 4

Applying this mapping gives us the “same motif” but now in a 5-note scale:

Repeated Motif in a 5-Note Scale

We can interpret this 5-note scale as a major pentatonic, which then gives us

Repeated Motif in Major Pentatonic

Or we could interpret it as the minor pentatonic:

Repeated Motif in Minor Pentatonic

We keep using that same 3-note scale motif, but we keep getting different results because we keep taking it through different paths on its way up to the diatonic scale.

Using a Chord as a Scale

Let’s try another trick. Let’s take our repeated motif and this time map it into a 4-note scale. So far all of our transformations have preserved octave relationships (that is to say, if two notes are one octave apart before we map them, they are one octave apart after we map them.) But music is supposed to be free, man. There are no rules here. So let’s just reinterpret the motif as a 4-note scale:

Reinterpreted Motif in a 4-Note Scale

Now instead of giving a constant mapping from our 4-note scale into something playable, let’s instead give a dynamic mapping. For example, here’s a nice chord progression:

A Nice Chord Progression

You’ll notice that each of these chords has four notes. And we have a motif that is in a 4-note scale… so what if we to map our motif to the notes of the progression?

The details here are pretty finicky, so I’ve notated this one as a grand staff. The first system is the chord progression, the second is the 4-note scale motif. The third system is the chord tones that get targeted by each note in the motif, and the final system is after we have applied all the accidentals from the motif to the targeted chord tones.

Derivation of Our Motif Over Chords

Remember that the bottom line on the 4-note staff represents the “tonic” note, which is the lowest note of each chord. So because the first note of the motif is on the tonic, and the lowest note of the first chord is F, the resulting note is F.

The note in our motif is just the next 4-note above the tonic, which is the second note in our chord, thus we get an Ab.

But the third note of the motif is a #/7 above the second note in the chord. So since the second note in our chord is Ab (third system), one diatonic step above that is Bb (fourth system).

The fourth note of the motif is a b/12 below the next note in the chord. The next note of the chord is C, so we lower it by a flat and get Cb. And then the last note of the motif is just the same note of the chord, but this time without the flat — thus C.

That’s the derivation of the first bar. So far, so good. The second bar makes things a little trickier. This time the motif starts on the first space, which is to say it begins on the second note up the chord. Since the motif only touches three notes of the chord, in the second bar we will be ignoring the root note of the chord (the low F).

It’s worth tracing through the details on this example. It’s finicky, but really makes you appreciate why we might want to use computers to calculate this stuff on our behalf.

As one final step, we might want to take the last system of our derivation and “renormalize” it — changing the spelling of the notes so they feel a little more natural:

Renormalized Results

Whew! We made it to the end!

If you’re been paying attention to the whole series of blog posts, there’s nothing new here, but perhaps having a few more worked examples might help some of the ideas land. And again, none of these are my ideas — they all come from Tonality.

What is mine is the notation, which I think can help with understanding. Of course, you’d never actually want to do any of these transformations by hand, but seeing them illustrated in full might perhaps pull back the curtains on composition.

Perhaps what set apart the great composers of yore was not their musical genius, but their patience to work through the details of all these fiddly transformations.

←